By Janine Jansen, SAEP Tertiary Support Manager
First published in the City Press, 14 August 2016
Most South African youth are set up to fail. In my years working with township youth, I have consistently witnessed learners selecting tertiary study opportunities based on their perceived earning power and social status. They want to be doctors, lawyers, psychologists or any other career they believe to be prestigious. And in a country like South Africa where the winners win big, who can blame them? Technical Vocational Education and Training (TVET) Colleges are considered as low status and very few learners know of learnerships and apprenticeships, but with SA universities only able to accommodate 20% of our young people, the odds are stacked against them.
Funneled through an education system designed to sort the most capable of abstraction from the rest, learners hold a narrowly defined notion of success centered on acceptance into university. And, for township learners in particular, the idea of admission is laden with the expectation of gainful employment and an opportunity to improve their family’s living conditions. However, the sad reality is that the majority of these young people will not meet the necessary entry criteria and, in fact, do not even know what these criteria are. And for those that do make it in, acceptance is only the first of their hurdles as, even though the chances of gaining entry to university has improved for our black youth, almost half will drop out, often as a result of improper career guidance.
For those coming from poorer communities, high school education is seen as the pathway straight to university with very little consideration given to learner’s interest, their capabilities and their school grades. Learners are encouraged to ‘dream big’ with no regard as to what is achievable given their aptitudes, marks or what universities actually offer. Of course, with research showing that young people with a tertiary qualification have much lower unemployment rates – as low as 2% for white graduates and 6% for black graduates, results which are very flattering in comparison with the 29% unemployment rate of learners with only a matric – the desirability of such a qualification is understandable, but, without the proper support, learners are left to make unrealistic decisions about their study and career choices and unwittingly place themselves at centre stage of an unfortunate situation.
Ill prepared for the new type of academic learning on offer, many students enrolled for university courses they are not suited to, show poor academic performance or fail their courses; their dreams of success and opportunity quickly turning into nightmares as they shoulder the cost of a large government loan and the shame of having to face their friends and family. Buried under this enormous disappointment and debt, learners are prevented from discovering and harnessing their true potential and finding suitable education and training opportunities – ones which align with their strengths and interests and also allow them to support their families.
While organisations such as the South African Education and Environment Project (SAEP) run successful programmes designed to assist and support students from lower socio-economic backgrounds to enroll and remain in tertiary institutions, what is needed is a nationwide shift in our approach to career guidance. Learners need more than information to make appropriate career choices, they need engagement and support. Too often career guidance is limited to the life orientation curriculum and forms a small part of the syllabus presented by teachers who are not career guidance practitioners. We need to move away from this state of passivity to a much more engaged approach where learners’ career choices and the viability of their plans are followed up on and explored.
High schools and tertiary institutions of all kinds need to work in tandem to ensure that learners have adequate information that shows a variety of pathways and study options. We need alternative stories. The university dream is not the only story of success that exists. We need learners and youth to engage with the stories of their peers who have found success studying at TVET Colleges or through learnerships or apprenticeships. We need to widen the net in order to catch more students.
Janine Jansen is the Tertiary Support Manager for the South African Education and Environment Project (SAEP). The SAEP Bridging Year programme prepares recent matriculants for tertiary study and the SAEP Tertiary Support programme assists at-risk students in tertiary institutions to graduate. SAEP relies on donor funding to run its programmes, to make a donation click through here.